It's been a while since my last book review, but I have not been hurting for books. Can't.stop.reading!
Anyway, after hearing wonderful things about The Four Season Harvest by Eliot Coleman (Chelsea Green, 1999), I finally checked it out from my local library.
I was a little concerned about the fact that this book was written by someone who lives in Maine.
In case you have been dead to the world, I live in California [pronounced Kahl e FOR neee yaaa, per Schwarzenegger] and we're about as opposite in weather as states can get. But I also enjoyed The Vegetable Gardener's Bible by Edward C. Smith, and he is in Maine. There was some reviews of this book on Amazon that also turned me off for some reason. They certainly shouldn't have.
We got some really, and I do mean really great advice from this book.
After reading Gaia's Garden: A Guide to Home-scale Permaculture by Toby Hemenway, this book was a natural progression for us. We've been using techniques from Gaia's Garden in planning our gardens, and was a big reason we sheet mulched the backyard (water conservation, worm habitat, and dense plantings of diverse plants that shade the soil to come). I guess I ought to get around to reviewing that book as well, huh?
The dense planting technique from Gaia's Garden used in context with this book shows you that all you have to do to have loads of great winter vegetables is plant them in the late summer and into fall (this varies depending on where you live), and give them protection based on how cold it gets in your neck of the woods. For us, that usually means nothing more than low tunnels (we built the raised beds with hollow 4" x 4" posts for the sole purpose of running tubing through them and draping frost blankets over them in the winter. Perhaps we'll actually do that next year!). For colder areas of the country, cold frame and green houses may be more appropriate.
I liked The Four Season Harvest because like Gaia's Garden, there is no such thing as "putting the garden to bed." I can't tell you how depressing it is right now in April to not be able to garden all that much because I'm waiting to be able to plant things out (it's been obscenely cold for April here - but any day now we should be 98% in the clear). Chris and I didn't plan real well in the fall, which is when most things are supposed to be planted here.
NorCal Tidbit
Most things that folks plant in the spring and harvest in the late summer/fall in cooler climates MUST be planted in fall here in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Valley in Northern California. Our springs get very warm very quickly (spring becomes summer in one week flat many years), and our springs acts more like other folks' summers. Our summers can reach 110o+ in a bad year as well.
The most interesting discussion of the book was about a little green named mache. Chris and I planted this a few months back, and it HATES the hot weather (we're having it all for dinner in the next few days before it bolts). BUT it is the most COLD-TOLERANT green, and apparently it is even tastier after cold weather has set in. I've taken some of the leaves off of our mache plants and nibbled them, and they are delicious (this coming from "not really a salad lover" of a person like me. For the record, I NEVER ate vegetables until I met Chris. I'm convinced it is why I am so short to this day).
It's becoming more difficult to find books about gardening that aren't repetitive for me. Everyone tends to kind of say the same thing. This book was a breath of fresh air because it gave us lots of new information to chew on. (Or maybe it was just packaged in a way I hadn't seen it before). I especially enjoyed the talk about summer and winter crops, bed preparation for both and specific plants (this was new), climate resources appendix in the back (maps of the US and Europe with varying information, and dates to plant items based on your first frost date), and although there wasn't many pictures but instead lots of small drawings, Eliot Coleman does a fantastic job of explaining things in a way that everyone can understand.
Cons: None. Great book, start to finish.
This is definitely a book I would love to have in my library. Hopefully someday during our weekly Farmer's Market-Used Book Store trek, I'll come across it and pick it up.
Grade: A+
Apr 23, 2008
Book Review: The Four Season Harvest
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
It's interesting to hear about the specifics of your weather. The other day you were talking about blueberries and I was curious if you could actually grow them in CA.
I have this book and agree that it's awesome but I have yet to build a cold frame or hoop house myself. Hopefully this fall, I'll find some time and cover my cold season crops.
That seems like another great book, I'll have to check it out. Before I can even worry about planting for every season, I have to get one season of things to grow...lol. My greenslings are dying! They're just flopping over. The peat is moist and I have them in front of a south facing window on a table like you have yours. Only, mine are in little jiffy greenhouse flats. I wonder whats the matter...Do you think they'd do better without the lid? I had the same problem with my marigolds back a few months. Everything seems to grow and then they flop over and turn to mush, they need viagra or something. lol. Everything seems to be fine with my ghetto greenhouse bottles though. Do you think with the lids they don't get enough oxygen?
I have got to get that book. It's one of those that's been on my list forever, but I haven't gotten around to it.
You guys might like John Jeavons' How to Grow More Vegetables, which has a lot about succession planting, companion plants, and intensive planting. We have the same garden book problem as you, which is that we see a lot of the same stuff over and over, but the Jeavons book was a nice change.
Those are my two favorites. I read Gaia's Garden and then Four Season Harvest. I think I like them most because they make me think outside of the box, and they encourage experimenting and learning as you grow.
living in central new york makes this one a tad more relevant, its on my short list for late summer reading. Now to see if I can get a hoop house past the "commitee"
ok, on thing I forgot, sorry. Speaking of april weather, it has been ridiculously hot. Usually you can set your watch by the spring blooming. Hyacinths and Daffodils first, A few trees, tulips, then the rest of the trees.
This year is all kinds of messed up. Microclimates seem to be mattering more than average temp in the area. The tulips are stumpy and weak, and the other bulbs dont look so great either.
We never really got spring, it went from the end of winter to summer. I thinkyou guys must have gotten all of it.
Anthony - they grow berries about 30 miles east of here where it's a little colder. We bought some southern blueberry bushes (rabbiteye? highbush? I dunno), so since they do well in the South, they might have a chance here. Looking forward to mache in the dead of winter!
Garrett - once my seedlings sprout in their covered little starter greenhouse, I take off the lid. This way they can dry out a little and not "damp off".
Meg - this is a good one to add to your list, for sure. And since you keep recommending Jeavon's book, I'll have to get it...
Melinda - those 2 are my favorites as well. Love them!
Spelled with a k - I really think you'd enjoy this book - it snows where you're at. If it makes you feel better, we're having a cold spring (late frosts are doing major damage to California crops in our valley). Yikes! It went from spring to summer in like a week last year, so I feel your pain...
Post a Comment
I hope to reply to comments, but don't always get around to it. Please know they are all read and appreciated. Spam and otherwise icky messages will be deleted at my discretion.
Thanks for visiting!